Shingle vs. Tile vs. Metal: which roof lasts longer in South Florida?

Shingle vs. Tile vs. Metal: which roof lasts longer in South Florida?

If you’re getting quotes in Miami-Dade or Broward, you’ll hear a lot about materials. Durability is usually the first question—and it should be, because our heat, UV, salt air, and storms age roofs faster than in other states. Here’s a plain-English comparison to help you choose the roof that fits your budget and how long you plan to stay in the home.

The quick takeaway

• Asphalt shingle: most affordable; typical Florida lifespan about 15–20 years.

• Tile (concrete/clay): the tiles can last 50+ years, but the underlayment beneath them often needs replacement around 20–25 years here.

• Metal (standing seam or metal shingles): usually 40–70 years, with top performance when the system is designed for coastal conditions.

Below, let’s break down what those numbers mean in real life—by climate, maintenance, and code.

Asphalt shingle: good value, shorter service life

In Florida’s sun-and-storm cycle, architectural asphalt shingles often reach 15–20 years before aging out. Heat and UV harden the asphalt; wind events can loosen or remove tabs; and you’ll eventually see granules washing into gutters. Shingles are the lowest upfront cost and easiest to repair, which makes them a fit if you expect to move in the next decade or want the best price today.

Wind rating matters: If you pick shingles, ask for products with ASTM D7158 Class H (laboratory tested up to 150 mph) and make sure the installation matches the manufacturer’s pattern, especially at edges and corners. In Florida’s code, high-rated shingles (ASTM D3161 Class F or D7158 Class H) are approved for all wind zones when installed per instructions.

Who should choose shingles? Homeowners prioritizing lowest upfront price who are comfortable with a ~15–20-year horizon and regular checkups after big storms.

Tile (concrete or clay): long-lived tiles, mid-life underlayment

Tile is iconic in South Florida for a reason: it performs well against sun and rain and can easily outlast a generation. But remember the system is tiles + underlayment + fasteners/foam. While the tiles may go 50–100 years, the underlayment (your true water barrier) typically reaches end-of-life in about 20–25 years in our climate, which is why many “tile roof replacements” are actually tile-off, replace underlayment, and reset good tiles. Budget for that mid-life service when you compare quotes.

Tile roofs are heavier, so your deck and fastening pattern must match the product approval. In HVHZ (Miami-Dade/Broward), installers follow Miami-Dade NOAs that spell out foam/bead contact area, fastener counts, and edge details—small specifics that make a big difference in storms.

Who should choose tile? If you love the look, plan to stay long term, and are fine with a scheduled underlayment refresh around year 20–25, tile offers excellent curb appeal and longevity.

Metal (especially standing seam): longest single-owner lifespan

A properly designed and installed metal roof commonly lasts 40–70 years, which is two to three times longer than a typical shingle roof. Metal excels at shedding water, handling wind when panel clips/fasteners are engineered correctly, and reflecting heat (cool-roof coatings). Standing seam systems avoid exposed screws, reducing long-term maintenance.

Coastal tip: Near salt air, favor aluminum (or coastal-grade Galvalume with PVDF paint) to resist corrosion; galvanized steel can rust prematurely at the beach. Many Florida pros recommend aluminum standing seam for homes within ~1,500 feet of the ocean.

Who should choose metal? Homeowners planning to stay for decades, or those who want the best life-cycle cost with minimal replacements—especially in coastal zones where corrosion-resistant metal shines.

How code and approvals affect durability

In Florida—and especially in the HVHZ counties—durability isn’t just material; it’s approved systems + correct installation. Ask your contractor to list the exact Florida Product Approval or Miami-Dade NOA for the shingle/tile/metal system, underlayment, fasteners, and accessories in your estimate. These documents specify the wind ratings, fastening schedules, and edge/valley details that help your roof survive real storms.

Choosing by time horizon (real-world planning)

• 0–10 years in the home: Shingle can be the right value play. Keep it Class H and get regular inspections.

• 10–25 years: Tile makes sense if you’re okay planning for an underlayment refresh mid-way.

• 20–40+ years: Metal typically offers the longest run with the fewest replacements, especially near the coast (choose aluminum or PVDF-coated alloys).

Bottom line

• Shingle: lowest upfront, ~15–20 years in FL.

• Tile: tiles 50+ years, but underlayment ~20–25 years.

• Metal: 40–70 years, best when specified for coastal corrosion.

  
  

  Comparing life-cycle cost (how many times you’ll replace during ownership) often moves metal or tile ahead—even if the first price is higher.

Ready to compare options for your exact home and location? Tap the button to call The Roofing Knight. We’ll inspect, explain shingle vs. tile vs. metal for your property, and provide an apples-to-apples quote with the right Florida approvals.

Click Me